Noble Crust Wins Our Readers’ “Favorite Restaurant In Wesley Chapel” Title For 2025!

Noble Crust Is Our Readers’ Favorite Restaurant In Wesley Chapel! 

Popular ‘Southern Italian’ Eatery At Shops At Wiregrass Reclaims Top Spot From Cooper’s Hawk! 

 All it took was taking chain restaurants with more than 10 locations off the ballot (while still allowing those who entered the contest to write in any of the chains among their favorites) for last year’s Favorite Restaurant in Wesley Chapel — Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant — to drop from #1 to #17. 

Moving back up into the top spot, after dropping to #4 in Wesley Chapel last year (following three years in a row at #1) is Noble Crust, the “Southern Italian” restaurant that has been in the top-5 with our readers every year since it opened. Chief marketing officer Bradley Elia (far right in photo) was so excited to regain the top spot that he decided to include his entire Wesley Chapel team in the picture on this page — and we, of course, were happy to oblige! 

But, as usual, this year’s Reader Dining Survey & Contest wasn’t without its own pratfalls. While many more locally-owned, mom-&-pop eateries made it into the Top-25s in both Wesley Chapel and New Tampa, I couldn’t help but notice that the last few categories on this year’s ballot all received far less than the 450+ total votes cast by the readers in both of our distribution areas. The last two categories — “Favorite Bakery in New Tampa (NT) & Wesley Chapel (WC)”and “Favorite Coffee in NT & WC” — each received at least 100 fewer total votes than “Favorite Restaurant in Wesley Chapel.” 

To that end, I plan to go back to only one or two categories in the ten WC issues of the paper between February and November of 2026 and allow everyone to vote as many times as they want in each category. 

The Readers Have Spoken! Noble Crust Is Your Favorite Restaurant In Wesley Chapel! Stonewood Is Still Your #1 Favorite In New Tampa! But, Did You Win Free Dining? Read On! 

The “bad” news is that, despite my best efforts to make it easier for you to enter, fewer of our readers — 450 vs. nearly 600 — entered this year’s Dining Survey & Contest. 

The good news, however, is that my intention of having more mom-&-pop, individually-owned restaurants make it to the Top-25 this year — by again not including the names of the chain restaurants with more than 10 locations on the ballots — DID work, especially here in Wesley Chapel. 

Case in point: Moving up into the Top- 25 in WC this year were the Happy Hangar Café (#11), Rice-N-Beans Puerto Rico (#14), Brunchies (#16), NY NY Pizza (#21), Latin Twist Café (#23), Burger Monger (#234) and Mama B’s Pizzeria (#25). 

Those seven restaurants replaced the following restaurants — all of which are at least mini-chains: the out-of-business Chuck Lager (which was #9 last year), Ford’s Garage (dropped out from #10), Glory Days Grill (from #15), Bahama Breeze (from #17), Bubba’s 33 (from #19), The Hungry Greek (from #22) and First Watch (from #23) 

Meanwhile, in our New Tampa voting, there were eight restaurants that made it into this year’s Top-25 which did not last year, and all but one of them aren’t chain eateries. 

The newest of them was Box of Cubans, which debuted at a solid #9 with our readers this year. Others moving into the Top-25 included: Ha Long Bay (#12), Michi Ramen (#13), Cantina Mexican Restaurant (#18), Zio’s NY Bagel & Deli (#19), Koizi Endless Hibachi & Sushi (#22), The Little Greek (#23 & the only chain among the newcomers) and Bayscape Bistro (#24). 

Dropping out of the Top-25 in New Tampa were: EggTown Breakfast & Lunch (#9 last year), Hungry Crab Juicy Seafood (from #13), Fresh Kitchen (from #14), Lima Peruvian Cuisine (from #15 down to #27), Thai Lanna (from #18), Taste of NY Pizza (from #21), Burger 21 (from #22), and Gorkhali Kitchen & Peabody’s (which tied for #25 last year). 

As for the restaurants that moved up in the rankings from where they were last year in Wesley Chapel, they are Noble Crust, which bounced back from #4 last year up to its fourth #1 ranking in the past five years; Grillsmith (from #3 up to #2), Zukku-San (from #11 up to #4), The Living Room (from #6 up to #5), Señor Tequila (from #14 up to #6), Falabella Family Bistro (from #12 up to #7) Umu Japanese & Thai (from #16 up to #9), EggTown Breakfast & Lunch (from #20 up to #15), Crazy Sushi (from #25 up to #19), Arroy Thai (from #24 up to #22) and this year’s most upwardly mobile WC restaurant — Amici Pizza, which rose all the way up to #10 from #21 last year! 

Only a few WC eateries that stayed in the Top-25 actually dropped, with the biggest fall being Cooper’s Hawk Wine Bar & Restaurant — from #1 down to #17, despite how packed the place is every day. Not falling nearly as far were Azteca D’Oro (from #2 down to #3), Los Vallartas (from #5 to #12, Mac’s Custom Meats & Deli (from #7 down to #13) and PizzaMania (from #13 down to #20). 

Meanwhile, the New Tampa restaurants that finished lower in the Top-25 this year than last, are: Liang’s Bistro (from #4 last year down to #6), The Grill at Morris Bridge (from #6 down to #8), Johnny C’s Italian Eatery (from #12 down to #14), Cappy’s Pizzeria (from #16 down to #21, Las Palmas (from #2 down to #20), and Thai Ruby from #19 down to #25). 

There were two restaurants in each of our distribution areas that remained in the exact same spot they finished last year. Here in Wesley Chapel, the Florida Ave. Brewing Co. remained at #8 and Yamato Japanese Restaurant stayed at #18. Over in New Tampa, Stonewood remained our readers’ #1 Favorite for the 10th year in a row and Mr. Dunderbak’s continued to hold down the #7 ranking. 

Changes Coming For 2026 

As I said on page 1, one of the trends I couldn’t help but notice was that the deeper into this year’s survey our readers got, the fewer votes there were cast in that category. Nearly all of the 450+ ballots cast included at least some (but definitely not all complete) Top-5 votes in each reader’s distribution area (although not all of the ballots cast were by people who live in, or even close to, New Tampa or Wesley Chapel). Just about 100 of those who entered didn’t vote for a Top-5 at all in the other market, which I’ll admit was a little disappointing for yours truly. I honestly run this contest every year not just to fill space but to really let the restaurants in both of our distribution areas know what our readers think about not only them but also their competitors. 

The year that generated the most response, only a few years ago, was when I only put two or, at the most, three categories in each issue and let all of you enter as often as you wanted. That generated more than 1,500 total entries and didn’t give anyone the chance to get bored midway through marking their ballots. 

I am seriously considering going back to that format, I would just again only allow either online (on our website) or emailed ballots — the much smaller entry forms were much easier to lose when they came in by U.S. Mail. I also plan to start the balloting earlier in the year, when no one is away on summer vacation and I can fit in more categories. I may even up our Grand Prize to $500 in FREE dining. So, do me a favor and keep an eye out for it! 

Anyway, congratulations to the readers who won this year’s FREE, drawn at random (from all correctly-submitted entries) dining prizes (see yellow box at the top of this page) and of course, to all of our ranking restaurants. 

But, please realize that if you did win a prize, 1) you have to tell me which restaurant you want a gift card to and 2) I am no longer putting those prizes in the mail, so please call or email me to claim your prize! — GN 

2025 Dining Survey & Contest – Wesley Chapel Top-25 

1. Noble Crust (photo) 

2. Grillsmith 

3. Azteca D’Oro 

4. Zukku-San 

5. The Living Room 

6. Señor Tequila 

7. Falabella Family Bistro 

8. Florida Ave. Brewing Co. 

9. Umu Japanese & Thai 

10. Amici Pizza 

11. Happy Hangar Café 

12. Los Vallartas 

13. Mac’s Custom Meats & Deli 

14. Rice N Beans Puerto Rico 

15. EggTown Breakfast & Lunch 

16. Brunchies 

17. Cooper’s Hawk Wine Bar & Restaurant 

18. Yamato Japanese Restaurant 

19. Crazy Sushi 

20. PizzaMania 

21. NY NY Pizza 

22. Arroy Thai 

23. Latin Twist Café 

24. Burger Monger 

25. Mama B’s Pizzeria 

2025 Dining Survey & Contest – New Tampa Top-25 

1. Stonewood Grill & Tavern (photo) 

2. Via Italia Wood Fired Pizza & Bar 

3. Kobé Japanese Steakhouse 

4. Fat Rabbit Pub 

5. Cali Tampa Palms 

6. Liang’s Bistro Asian Cuisine 

7. Mr. Dunderbak’s Bier Garten 

8. The Grill at Morris Bridge 

9. Box of Cubans 

10. Acropolis Greek Taverna 

11. Minerva Indian Restaurant 

12. Ha Long Bay 

13. Michi Ramen 

14. Johnny C’s Italian Eatery 

15. Sushi Café 

16. Frammi American Grille & Italian Food 

17. Don Julio’s Mexican Restaurant 

18. Cantina Mexican Restaurant 

19. Zio’s NY Bagel & Deli 

20. Las Palmas Latin Grille 

21. Cappy’s Pizza 

22. Koizi Endless Hibachi & Sushi 

23. The Little Greek 

24. Bayscape Bistro 

25. Thai Ruby 

2025 Dining Survey & Contest — Your #1-#10 Favorite Restaurants In Wesley Chapel! 

1. Noble Crust 

28330 Paseo Dr., Shops at Wiregrass 

(813) 703-2602 • Noble-Crust.com 

Even though it was bumped down to #4 Favorite last year by our readers after a three-peat in the top spot, Noble Crust’s “Deep South Italian” fare and always-cool vibe moved it back up into this year’s #1 Favorite in Wesley Chapel ranking with our readers. 

From upscale and unusual items like pear and burrata pizza (right) and comfort foods like boneless crispy chicken wings (below left) and rigatoni beef ragu (below right), plus the always-happening craft cocktail bar, Noble Crust continues to please the masses in Wesley Chapel. 

And, with its seasonally changed menu, there’s probably something new you haven’t tried that should bring you back,
especially if it’s been a while since you last visited. 

2. Grillsmith 

2000 Piazza Ave., #100, Shops at Wiregrass 

(813) 907-1900 • Grillsmith.com 

Grillsmith has consistently finished in the top-5 among our readers’ favorites every year and moved up one spot from last year’s #3 “Favorite in Wesley Chapel.” 

This five-unit mini-chain continues to offer a large menu (photo, right) of quality American cuisine, including always-fresh fish plus assortments of flatbreads, salads, steaks, burgers, chicken (like the lemon feta chicken, right) and pasta options that keep our readers coming back for more. 

Like its fellow Shops at Wiregrass staple Noble Crust, Grillsmith also is a popular weekend brunch spot with everything from bananas Foster French toast to chicken & waffles Benedict and always attracts an upscale bar crowd, too. 

3. Azteca D’Oro Mexican Restaurant 

2000 Piazza Ave., #170, The Shops at Wiregrass 

(813) 527-6033 • AztecaDOro.com 

Rounding out The Shops at Wiregrass mall’s consistent top-3 is Azteca D’Oro, which has never finished lower than third in WC with our readers. 

From the gorgeous ultra-premium bar (with an amazing tequila selection) to upscale, authentic Mexican fare, like the mixed grill known as parrillada (right), plus outstanding appetizer like made-tableside guacamole, Azteca D’Oro aims to please. 

4. Zukku-San Sushi Bar & Grill 

25916 Sierra Center Blvd., Lutz 

(813) 419-1351 • ZukkuSushi.com 

Although there are a lot of Japanese and other Asian restaurants in our area, there’s a reason why Zukku-San moved back up into this year’s top-5 faves in WC — consistently fresh sushi that is served on unique art palettes and always-imaginative menu options like the sushi tacos shown here. It also has the best variety of appetizers, including all different kinds of veggie tempura. 

Zukku-San also is one of only a handful of Japanese restaurants boasting a full-liquor bar and you definitely need to try its new weekend brunch — especially the fried chicken and ube waffles. 

5. The Living Room 

2001 Piazza Ave., #100, The Shops at Wiregrass 

(813) 934-7911 • TLR.Restaurant 

Despite the continuing complaints online about its automatic 20% service charge, there’s obviously a lot our readers like about The Living Room, which moved up to give The Shops at Wiregrass four of the top-5 Favorites in WC this year. 

The Living Room definitely brings a creative touch and an ever-changing menu to go with its tasty craft cocktails. 

6. Señor Tequila 

1640 Bruce B. Downs Blvd., Shoppes at New Tampa of Wesley Chapel 

(813) 428-5411 • TheSenorTequila.com 

Jumping up eight places to its highest-ever finish with our readers is the second Mexican restaurant to crack this year’s top ten — Señor Tequila. 

With its huge menu, it can be hard to make a decision, so why not try the Señor Tequila Sampler appetizer shown here? 

Also offering great Happy Hour, Margarita Tuesday and Thirsty Thursday specials at its beautiful premium-liquor bar. 

7. Falabella Family Bistro 

6027 Wesley Grove Blvd., Suite 105 • The Village at The Grove 

(813) 428-6957 • FalabellaBistro.com 

I’ll admit that I was surprised when Falabella Family Bistro fell out of our readers’ Top-10 in WC last year, considering how delicious and creative its food is — including the creamy cajun trio (shrimp, chicken & Italian sausage) bucatini pasta shown here — the fact that the place is elegant, but comfortable, there are different specials every week, the bar has full premium liquor (and a great wine selection) and the owner is Steve Falabella. 

8. Florida Avenue Brewing Co. 

2029 Arrowgrass Dr. (at S.R. 56), Wesley Chapel 

(813) 452-6333 • FloridaAveBrewing.com 

Although Florida Avenue Brewing Co., keeps changing its food menu, one thing hasn’t change — how much our readers enjoy it! With newer items like General Tso’s cauliflower and Gulf Coast mahi & chips, plus standards like Florida Ave. wings and cheese curds (photo), it also has a large, comfortable bar that features not only the in-house brewery’s many beers, ciders and seltzers, but also premium full liquor, it’s easy to understand why Florida Ave. Brewing Co. continues to be among our readers’ favorites. 

9. Umu Japanese & Thai 

2653 Bruce B. Downs Blvd., #120A • Wesley Chapel 

(813)591-6121 • UmuJapanese.com 

There’s no doubt that Umu Japanese & Thai continues to grow in popularity (jumping seven places this year to #9) because people love the restaurant’s amazing selection of fresh sushi, both standard and exotic, at its beautiful sushi bar, plus “From the Kitchen” favorites like Umu Teri (with marinated chicken or NY strip steak), Chilean Seabass Misoyaki and Pad Thai. The restaurant also is elegant and intimate and offers imported and domestic beer, wine and sake. 

10. Amici Pizza 

26602 Wesley Chapel Blvd. (CR 54) • Lutz 

(813) 973-9734 • Amici-Pizza.com 

Even though Amici didn’t win for Favorite Pizza Place in NT/WC (it finished third), the long-time local favorite soared to its highest-ever “Favorite restaurant in WC” finish in our Reader Survey with its 10th-place finish this year. 

Yes, our readers love the NY-style pizza, but also the real Italian favorites like chicken, eggplant or shrimp parmigiana, chicken Marsala, linguine with clams, meatball and Philly cheese steak subs and so many more. The Mannino brothers are great people serving delicious Italian food. 

Your Favorite Pizza Places In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

Both of last year’s Favorite Pizza places repeated as the favorites in their distribution areas, even though we didn’t divide the competition this year into New Tampa & Wesley Chapel. Via Italia again got the most votes overall, with NY NY second. 

1. Via Italia (photo) 

2. NY NY Pizza 

3. Amici Pizza 

4. PizzaMania 

5. (tie) Taste of NY Pizza 

5. (tie) Mama B’s Pizzeria 

Your Favorite Burger Places In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

After not having a Favorite Burger category last year, we brought it back this year and Burger Monger snuck past Fat Rabbit Pub by only two votes. 

Burger 21, Culver’s and Mac’s were all several votes behind the two leaders, but I think the burger category is back to stay. 

1. Burger Monger (photo) 

2. Fat Rabbit Pub 

3. Burger 21 

4. Culver’s 

5. Mac’s Custom Meats & Deli 

Your Favorite Chicken Places In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

Four of the top-5 finishers in this category legitimately specialize in chicken — Raising Cane’s for its tenders and Fat Rabbit, locally famous for its wings, took the top two spots, with Chick-fil-A and Chick’n Fun close behind those two. 

1. Raising Cane’s (photo) 

2. Fat Rabbit Pub 

3. Chick-fil-A 

4. Chick’n Fun 

5. Grillsmith 

Your Favorite Steak Places In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

This was perhaps the most competitive new category we had, at least for places 2-5, as Stonewood dominated the vote to take the top spot. Grillsmith and Grill at Morris Bridge were within a couple of votes of each other for 2nd & 3rd, as were Roadhouse & Kobe for 4th & 5th. 

1. Stonewood Grill & Tavern (photo) 

2. Grillsmith 

3. The Grill at Morris Bridge 

4. Texas Roadhouse 

5. Kobe Japanese Steakhouse 

Asian Restaurants In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

Congrats to Liang’s Bistro, but this was probably my biggest fear about this year’s contest — and it proved prophetic. 

Because so many of our readers in previous years have skipped voting for Favorite Chines, Favorite Japanese, Favorite Thai and Favorite Indian restaurants, I lumped them all into one category, which I will not do again. The separate categories will return next year, even if many people skip them. No Indian places made this year’s Top-7, with Minerva finishing 8th and only Umu making the top-5 among Thai places, with Thai Ruby finishing 6th, Arroy Thai 7th and Palm Thai 8th. 

1. Liang’s Bistro (photo) 

2. Zukku-San 

3. Umu Japanese & Thai 

4. Kobe Japanese Steakhouse 

5. Sushi Café 

Your Favorite Ice Cream/Frozen Yogurt In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

With locations in both NT and WC, Twistee Treat again grabbed the top spot over Ice Dreammm Shop, and by a wider margin this year. Surprising. Coldstone jumped up from #6 last year to #3 this year and 365 Caffé and Bruster’s both joined the Top-5 after missing the top-8 last year, with Le Macaron down to 8th. 

1. Twistee Treat (photo) 

2. Ice Dreammm Shop 

3. Coldstone Creamery 

4. 365 Caffe 

5. (tie) Bruster’s Real Ice Cream 

5. (tie) Ice Ssscreamin’ 

5. (tie) Culver’s 

Your Favorite Bars In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

Every time I post the Favorite Bar winners, I get comments like “Those are all restaurants, not bars.” Yes, I know, but with only three actual bar-only bars — The Brass Tap, Linkster’s and Joe Whiskey’s (see ad on pg. 53) — in NT & WC, and Jannah and I doing most of our dining at the restaurants with bars, I personally have no problem with Fat Rabbit Pub at #1 and any of these five taking down the top spots. Joe Whiskey’s did finish 7th and Brass Tap 8th in this year’s voting. 

1. Fat Rabbit Pub (photo) 

2. Florida Ave Brewing Co. 

3. Peabody’s 

4. Stonewood Grill & Tavern 

5. O’Brien’s Irish Pub 

Your Favorite Bakeries In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

This category was almost all newcomers, as the new Paris Baguette easily grabbed the top spot and Bakery X moving up from #3 to #2. But, I was surprised Publix got so many votes, beating out the two locations (one inside the Lotte Market) of Tous Les Jours and Moschella’s beating out Zio’s for #5, with Brooklyn Water Bagel dropping to #7 and The Cake Shop in at #8. 

1. Paris Baguette (photo) 

2. Bakery X 

3. Publix 

4. Tous les Jours 

5. Moschella’s 

Your Favorite Breakfast Places In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

All six of the breakfast places on the list below jockeyed for position as the votes came in this year, with Keke’s dropping from #1 last year to ties for 5th this year and EggTown’s two area locations ascending to the top spot, with First Watch, also with one location in NT and another in WC, jumping up to #2 after missing the top-8 last year. Brooklyn Water Bagel Co. finished 7th. 

1. EggTown Breakfast & Lunch (photo) 

2. First Watch 

3. Happy Hangar Café 

4. Brunchies 

5. (tie) Zio’s NY Bagel & Deli 

5 (tie) Keke’s Breakfast Café 

Your Favorite Coffee Places In Wesley Chapel & New Tampa 

This year’s Top-2 didn’t make the Top-5 last year, as Coffee Latitudes (8th last year) and Sorbo (6th) grabbed the most votes this year. Provisions and Macondo stayed close behind, but dropped from #2 to #3 and #3 to #4, respectively. The biggest surprise in this category was that last year’s top vote-getter, The Bean Bar, Co. dropped all the way to #6, behind Starbucks & just ahead of Bad Ass Coffee & Raining Berries. 

1. Coffee Latitudes Café (photo) 

2. Sorbo 

3. Provisions Coffee & Kitchen 

4. Macondo Coffee Roasters 

5. Starbucks