Gary’s 2023 Favorite Ice Cream Places In New Tampa & Wesley Chapel 

You’ll note that there are no frozen yogurt shops on this list, as rich, creamy ice cream will always be favored by yours truly over anything else. Quality toppings — like real hot fudge or chocolate dip tops — will help elevate some over others (like Leonidas; see pg. 40), but the Ice Dreammm Shop is still my go-to. 

1. Ice Dreammm Shop 

2. Bruster’s Real Ice Cream 

3. Ice Ssscreamin’ (temp. closed) 

4. Astro Craft Ice Cream 

5. Leonidas Chocolates Café 

6. Twistee Treat 

7. Cold Stone Creamery 

8. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream 

9. Culver’s 

10. 35 Below