Gary’s Favorite NY-Style Pizza in NT & WC 

1. New York New York Pizza 

As a native New Yawka, although I have nothing against other kinds of pizza — and there are lots of good options for those other types in New Tampa and Wesley Chapel — pizza to me has a thin crust, a certain kind of mozzarella (only) cheese and a certain tomato sauce taste. Some places have it but most simply don’t. 

However, all of the places on the list below come pretty close to the pizza I loved most in my home state, with NY NY coming closest of all.

2. Amici Pizza 

3. 900º Woodfired & NY Pizza 

4. Fratelli’s 

5 (tie). PizzaMania 

5. (tie) Taste of NY Pizza