Cold Stone Creamery Is The New Tampa Area’s Original Ice Cream Shop!

The people of New Tampa have now been hearing the phrase “Welcome to Cold Stone” for 20 years and even though many other ice cream shops have entered the local market (and many others have gone away), Cold Stone Creamery has been a constant source of joy for young and old alike. It features a unique selection of super-creamy, ultra-premium ice cream flavors, and a huge variety of toppings that you can have the happy Cold Stone ice creamers mix in from more than two dozen ingredients (bottom photo) — from fresh bananas, strawberries and raspberries to candies and cookies like Heath bars, Twix and Reese’s Oreos and toppings like real (but not hot) fudge, marshmallow, caramel and even pistachio cream sauce. 

New Tampa store general manager Nola Davis (above) says that this summer before the kids go back to school is a great time to try or return to Cold Stone, as there are several new flavors and new Signature Creations everyone can check out. 

For example, she says, “in honor of the recently released “Supergirl” movie, Cold Stone currently has ‘Supergirl’s Cosmic Kettle Corn’ (above left), which combines kettle corn-flavored ice cream, big pieces of kettle corn (above right), a caramel swirl and Supergirl-colored sprinkles.” 

Another current specialty creation is the OreoÂŽ Pretzel Perfection (left), which Nola says, “has a sweet cream-based, OreoÂŽ Cookie chocolate-covered pretzel ice cream, OreoÂŽ cookies, mini-pretzels, caramel and sugar crystals (below left).” 

There’s also a new “Cup & Cookie Chaos” (not pictured) that features Cookies ‘n’ Peanut Butter ice cream that is made with OreoÂŽ cookies, Reese’s peanut butter cups and OreoÂŽ Reese’s cookies. 

And finally, Nola says, the big hit of the summer so far is, “Our Dubai Chocolate Creation” (top photo). “It has our chocolate ice cream with pistachio cream, kataifi (finely shredded phyllo dough) and chocolate shavings. Everyone is crazy about Dubai chocolate these days. And, people are really loving it!” 

Nola even sent us home with samples of each creation, so we could all sample them. My favorite, not surprisingly, is the “Cup & Cookie Chaos,” but I can definitely finish off a serving of any of them. 

She adds, “Even if you pick one of our Signature Creations,” Nola says, “You can still make it your own.” 

All of these Signature and “Create Your Own” Creations can be put on your choice of a cone, cup or waffle bowl, in the usual Cold Stone sizes — Kid’s Size, “Like ItÂŽ,” “Love It®” and “Gotta Have ItÂŽ.” 

I had for me to not take one of these entire cakes home with me and finish it all myself. 

Nola also explains that although there is always a supply of ready-made cakes in the store (above right photo), including some of the “Perfect Pair” cakes, “Most of our cakes are custom-ordered, so you can always get whatever flavors of ice cream you want, toppings, everything, but please always give us at least two days to create the cake you want because someone has to build the cake and someone else will have to decorate it. Then, it has to stay in the freezer for a certain amount of time.” 

The New Tampa Cold Stone Creamery also offers different specials every Monday-Thursday, 11 a.m.-7 p.m. 

Monday is “Mega Monday!,” when you get one FREE “Like-it Create” creation with one mix-in when you purchase any two “Love-it” sizes (or larger). 

Tuesday is “2-for-$10 Tuesday!,” when you get any two “Like-it” creations (with one mix-in each) for only $10. 

Wednesday is “Waffle Wednesday!,” when you get a FREE plain waffle bowl or cone when you buy one “Love-it” size (or larger), 

Thursday is “Thriving Thursday!,” when you get $2 OFF any Cookies, Cupcakes or Reese’s Cups OR $5 OFF any Large-Size Signature Cake. 

And, right now, when you mention this story and present the coupon in the ad below, you’ll get a FREE scoop of ice cream! 

All of these offers are valid in-store at the Cold Stone location on Preserve Walk Ln. in New Tampa ONLY. Please note that they are not available with any other offers and are limited to one special per family/per order. 

We definitely agree with Nola that the summer is the best time of year to check out the New Tampa Cold Stone Creamery. Now you know why! 

New Tampa’s Cold Stone Creamery is located at 17519 Preserve Walk Ln., in the Highwoods Preserve area, just off I-75. It opens every day at 11 a.m. and stays open until 11 p.m. on Sunday, until 10 p.m. Monday-Thursday, and until midnight on Friday & Saturday. For more info, visit ColdStoneCreamery.com or call (813) 977-0024. 

Cold Stone Creamery Has New Energy To Go With Its New Owners! 

At the Cold Stone Creamery located off Bruce B. Downs Blvd. in New Tampa, co-owner Sunny Chaudhary (in white shirt) and his happy crew are always happy to fold in your favorite mix-ins into your favorite flavor (below left) from the store’s huge selection (below). (Photos by Charmaine George)

When we first brought up the idea of doing what we call a “Dining Feature story” about his Cold Stone Creamery location off (but visible from) Bruce B. Downs (Blvd.) in New Tampa, franchise co-owner Meet “Sunny” Chaudhary said he saw no reason for us to do so. 

“Pretty much everyone knows Cold Stone,” he said. “We’re a chain, like any other national chain restaurant.” 

But, while that is true — as Cold Stone has about 1,000 U.S. locations and another 300 around the world — I told Sunny that since his ads with us tout “Under New Ownership & New Energy,” didn’t he want to share that new energy with, oh, 80,000 or so of his “closest friends” in New Tampa’s 33647 zip code? 

So, Sunny — who only officially took over this 18-year-old location in May, with his partner, Sunny (not a misprint) Patel — did ultimately agree to be interviewed for this story. 

“Most of the people who had worked at this location didn’t stay when we took over,” Sunny admits. “But, we took that as a positive because we were able to bring on a whole new crew of young people, mostly high school students, who understand that Cold Stone Creamery isn’t just an ice cream place, it’s an experience.” 

To illustrate his point, he adds, “Every time someone walks in, we make sure every team member yells, ‘Welcome to Cold Stone!’ (Yes, they also sing songs for tips!) And, watching the crew mix in your favorite toppings on our cold stone counter is always fun, too. And, we stand behind our ice cream as the best, too!” 

The married Wesley Chapel resident says that when his uncles opened the new Cold Stone location in the Shoppes at New Tampa plaza on BBD in Wesley Chapel last year, he worked in the store as a team member, receiving the same training as any other employee, “So when this store became available, my partner and I decided, ‘Why not? Let’s run our own Cold Stone!’ even though we really were hoping to open a brand new location.” 

He notes, however, that he and Sunny still plan to open a new second location of their own, but in the meantime, he is focused on making sure that every time someone hears “Welcome to Cold Stone!,” they leave with a smile on their face. 

About The Ice Cream & Mix-Ins 

According to the company’s website, “After 35 years in business, Cold Stone Creamery continues to thrive by offering the Ultimate Ice Cream Experience®: a super-premium, artisanal ice cream that is made fresh in our stores, with an endless array of mix-in combinations that allows customers to dream up their own Cold Stone Signature Creations™.” 

My current favorite flavors are both new — Caramel Truffle and “Despicamallow” (the latter is marshmallow-flavored ice cream turned “Minion Yellow” to coincide with the release of the “Despicable Me 4” movie)— although I also am partial to Cold Stone’s banana, peanut butter, cake batter, “Classic Cookie Dough™” and cheesecake flavors. I also was a little surprised that even though I’m not usually a sorbet kind of guy, I genuinely enjoyed the peach mango sorbet, as well as the “SilkÂŽ Chocolate Almond Milk Frozen Dessert,” which is perfect for those who are lactose-intolerant. 

But, no matter which flavor is your favorite, or whether you order yours in “Kid’s Size,” “Like-It®” (small), “Love-It®” (medium) or “Gotta Have It®” (large) at Cold Stone, you always get to make your ice cream unique with the huge variety of available mix-ins. 

From fresh fruit, like bananas, raspberries and strawberries, to candy like M&Ms®, Kit Kat® and gummy bears, plus nuts like pecans and roasted almonds and “toppings” like real (not served hot, though) fudge, caramel, frosting and whipped topping (and too many more to name them all here), you can try different combinations every time you visit Cold Stone Creamery. Can’t decide? There also are plenty of actual Cold Stone “Signature Creations™,” from the “Mega Minion Marshmallow Meltdown” and “Peanut Butter Cup Perfection®” to “Mud Pie Mojo®” “Founder’s Favorite®” and many more. If you want to know what’s in each of these “Creations,”, visit ColdStoneCreamery.com or (my suggestion) stop into the store. 

And of course, not only is all of the ice cream made in-store, so are the waffle cones and bowls. 

“You can smell that, right?,” Sunny asked during the interview, as photographer Charmaine George and I nodded in approval. “I just love having that aroma hit me when I walk in the store.” 

Cakes, Shakes, Smoothies & Treats 
In addition to making your favorite creations in-store, Cold Stone also offers Reese’s® Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cups (above), Signature Ice Cream Cakes (below) like “Cake Batter Confetti™” & ice cream cookie sandwiches (below) in its freezer case at the front of the store.

In addition to those freshly made cones and cups, Cold Stone also offers other specialties, including fresh fruit smoothies (try the strawberry and blueberry) and hand-spun shakes (with your favorite ice cream flavor and mix-in). And, in the freezer at the front of the store, there’s also a variety of pre-packed quarts in four of those “Signature” flavors, as well as an even larger selection of Signature ice cream cakes, including the new “Heist Cream Cake” (featuring that Despicamallow ice cream), Cake Batter Confetti™ (photo on this page), “Midnight Delight®,” Oreo® Cookies & Extreme Cream” and many more in small (serves up to 8 people) and large (up to 14 people) round sizes. And of course, you can order completely customized cakes, with your favorite ice cream flavors, mix-in and frosting, in a number of different sizes. 

“I was never a big fan of ice cream cakes until I had ours,” Sunny says. “And we usually can create your custom cake within 24 hours.” 

Also available in the freezer at the front door are four-packs of ice cream cookie sandwiches and six-packs of ice cream cupcakes and my favorites, the Reese’sÂŽ Peanut Butter Ice Cream Cups. 

So, what are you waiting for? As Sunny says, “Ice cream brings out the kid in all of us!” 

The New Tampa location of Cold Stone Creamery (17519 Preserve Walk Ln.) is open every day at 11 a.m. and stays open until 10 p.m. Mon.-Thur. until 11 p.m. on Sun. and until midnight on Fri. & Sat. For more info, call (813) 977-0024, visit ColdStoneCreamery.com or see the ad below, where you’ll find this month’s Daily Store Specials. For special orders, call Sunny directly ay (813) 469-7954. 

Cold Stone Creamery — Celebrating 10 Years Of 10-Minute Vacations!

*IMG_4996By Gary Nager

As a certified (certifiable?) chocoholic and dessert lover who is trying to stay below 500 pounds, I don’t eat ice cream as much as I once did, but I still love a dish or a cone of super-premium ice cream every now and then, so I’ve been an ongoing, occasional customer of the Cold Stone Creamery located in the Highwoods Preserve section of New Tampa (just off Bruce B. Downs {BBD} Blvd.) since it opened nearly a decade ago.Continue reading