Garyโ€™s 2023 Favorite Ice Cream Places Inย New Tampa & Wesley Chapelย 

Youโ€™ll note that there are no frozen yogurt shops on this list, as rich, creamy ice cream will always be favored by yours truly over anything else. Quality toppings โ€” like real hot fudge or chocolate dip tops โ€” will help elevate some over others (like Leonidas; see pg. 40), but the Ice Dreammm Shop is still my go-to.ย 

1. Ice Dreammm Shop 

2. Brusterโ€™s Real Ice Cream 

3. Ice Ssscreaminโ€™ (temp. closed) 

4. Astro Craft Ice Cream 

5. Leonidas Chocolates Cafรฉ 

6. Twistee Treat 

7. Cold Stone Creamery 

8. Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream 

9. Culverโ€™s 

10. 35 Below 

Introducing Astro Craft Ice Creamโ€™s New Ice Cream Chef!

This is just a sampling f the delicious flavors at Astro Craft Ice Cream on S.R. 56. (All Photos by Charmaine George).

It was only six months or so ago when we first told you about the new Astro Craft Ice Cream, located in the same plaza on the north side of S.R. 56 as Mellow Mushroom.

Even so, thereโ€™s so much new happening at Astro that we knew we needed to update that story.

Still owned by Ferdian Jap and Gio Tran, the co-owners of Zukku-San Sushi (located about a 1/4-mile east of Astro) and Ato at the KRATE Container Park, Astro now has a new ice cream chef โ€” Adrian Carter. Carter, who is proud of his love of ice cream, completed an online course through the Auguste Escoffier School of Culinary Arts based in Boulder, CO, and also completed the intensive one-week Penn State University Ice Cream Short Course in University Park, PA, now in its 128th year โ€” where representatives of Ben & Jerryโ€™s, Baskin-Robbins, Blue Bell, Haagen-Dazs and many others have learned the secrets of ice cream making.

New Astro ice cream chef Adrian Carter prepares the signature sundae for June (below, left).

โ€œItโ€™s super-competitive,โ€ Carter says of the course. โ€œBut you really learn the best ways to make the best ice cream.โ€

Carter, who first met the Astro owners at their location at Armature Works near downtown Tampa, is proud of the changes heโ€™s already made to Astroโ€™s already delicious flavors and he promises to continue to add new varieties, starting with the unique new passion fruit-raspberry sorbet, which is made with oat milk, โ€œso it still has a creamy, more ice cream-like texture and taste,โ€ Carter says.

He also has made subtle changes to many of my already favorite flavors at Astro โ€” including adding real bananas to the banana pudding peanut butter cookie flavor (which is still my #1 favorite).

Carter says that most months, Astro offers a new โ€œsignatureโ€ creation. For June (which still has a few days left), the Fatherโ€™s Day-inspired special was the brown sugar whiskey cookie dough (made with a newly upgraded whiskey), with chocolate-covered pretzels, a caramel โ€œflavor shotโ€ and a sprinkle of brown sugar. Also new is the ube ice cream with dark chocolate chunks. Ube is a purple Fillipino yam (sweet potato) with a mellow flavor that blends well with the chocolate.

Astroโ€™s exclusive Cuban ice cream sandwich.
The revamped brownie sundae.

And, despite my concerns, Carter also has begun baking Astroโ€™s brownies and chocolate chip cookies in-house, rather than buying them from Mikeโ€™s Pies. I loved the Mikeโ€™s brownies, but the house-baked brownies are equally delicious, chewy and decadently dense โ€” so good as the base for a brownie sundae with a chocolate, caramel or honey flavor shot.

One thing Carter didnโ€™t mention changing was Astroโ€™s exclusive Cuban ice cream sandwich (above, right), made with Cuban bread from Tampaโ€™s La Segunda Bakery, pressed around Tampa guava cream cheese or creme brulรฉe cafรฉ con lechรฉ ice cream. So good.

Photographer Charmaine George and I both also raved about the cinnamon snickerdoodle marshmallow ice cream, made with marshmallow Fluff, graham crackers and lots of cinnamon. Charmaine said it โ€œtastes like Christmas.โ€ The seasonal flavor for July is red, white & blue vanilla ice cream, โ€œfor the kids,โ€ Carter says, adding that Astroโ€™s mobile ice cream van also is available for catered events. 

Astro Craft Ice Cream (25700 Sierra Center Blvd.) is open Mon.-Thur., noon-9:30 p.m.; 11 a.m.-10 p.m. on Fri. & Sat. & 11 a.m.-9 p.m. on Sun. For more info, visit AstroCraftIceCream.com, find the location on Facebook or Instagram.

A dish of the new passion fruit-raspberry sorbet with a honey flavor shot.